top of page

OUR MENU

Teafords Pizzas & Subs


Starters & More
Prices are listed as credit card payment. A 4% discount is applied to cash payments.

Boneless Wings
8 boneless wings, spicy or non-spicy
$7.80

Bone-In Wings
6 bone-in wings, spicy or non-spicy
$8.32

Loaded Nachos
Taco meat, onion, tomato, jalapeno, chips, side of nacho cheese & sour cream
$8.32

Chicken Strips
5 strips
$6.24

Corn Nuggets
10 nuggets
$6.24

Pepperjack Cheese Balls
20 cheese balls
$7.28

Spicy Pickle Spears
6 spears
$6.24

Mozzerella Sticks
5 sticks
$6.24

Potato Wedges
Seasoned wedges, single serving. Plain or loaded (taco meat, onion, nacho cheese, jalapeno)
plain
$4.68

loaded
$8.32

French Fries
Crinkle cut, single serving. Plain or loaded (taco meat, onion, nacho cheese, jalapeno)
plain
$3.64

loaded
$7.24



Pasta & Breads


Pretzel Breadsticks
Personal- 3 sticks, 1 sauce; Family- 6 sticks, 2 sauces
personal
$5.72

family
$10.40

Cheesy Bread
Personal- 9" with 1 sauce; Family- 14" with 2 sauces
personal
$7.23

family
$12.43

Original Breadsticks
Personal- 3 sticks, 1 sauce; Family- 6 sticks, 2 sauces
personal
$3.64

family
$6.24



Build Your Own
Meats: Pepperoni, Philly Meat, Chicken, American Sausage, Hamburger, Italian Sausage, Diced Bacon, Diced Ham, Salami, Bologna, Turkey or Ham Slices. Veggies: Mushrooms, Onions, Green Peppers, Black Olives, Green Olives, Pineapple, Banana Peppers, Sliced Tomato, Lettuce, Jalapeno, Pickles

BYO Pasta
8oz fettuccini pasta, choice of marinara or alfredo, with cheese. $1.04 each additional topping
$8.32

BYO Sub
Choice of sauce, 1 meat, 2 veggies, with cheese. $0.52 additional sauces/veggies, $1.56 additional meats
$8.32



Fresh Made 8" Subs
All subs are baked. Half subs not available. No exceptions.

Steak
Steak patty, mushrooms, onions, green peppers, cheese. Choice of no sauce, pizza, sauce, or mushroom gravy
$9.36

Sub Deluxe
Pizza sauce, pepperoni, salami, bologna, ham, mushroom, onion, green pepper, cheese
$10.40

BLT
8 slices of bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo
$10.40

Stromboli
Pizza sauce, italian sausage, mushroom, onion, green pepper, black olives, cheese
$9.36



Sauces & Extras


Sauces
Pizza Sauce, Ranch, Southwest Ranch, Honey Mustard, Buffalo Sauce, BBQ, Hot Sauce, Alfredo, Taco Sauce, Ketchup, Mustard, Mushroom Gravy, Sour Cream
$1.56

Garlic Butter
$1.30

Nacho Cheese Sauce
$2.08

Extra steak patty
$4.16

Extra meat or cheese
$2.08

Add/Extra anchovies
$4.16

Add/Extra tomato
$1.04

Add/Extra veggies/condiments
$0.52



Signature Pizzas
Available Crust Sizes: 9" Personal, 14" Small (serves 2-4), 16" Medium (serves 4-6), 18" Large (serves 6-8), Cauliflower (serves 1-2), Crustless (serves 1)

“Spud”tacular
Mashed potatoes, fresh green onions, bacon, cheddar and mozzarella cheeses
Personal
$13.52

Small
$22.88

Medium
$24.96

Large
$27.04

Cauliflower
$20.80

Crustless
$11.44

Taco
Taco meat & sauce, onions, black olives, jalapenos, fresh tomatoes, tortilla chips, and cheese. Sour cream on the side.
Personal
$13.52

Small
$22.88

Medium
$24.96

Large
$27.04

Cauliflower
$20.80

Crustless
$11.44

Deluxe
Pepperoni, american sausage, mushroom, onion, green pepper, and mozzarella cheese
Personal
$13.52

Small
$22.88

Medium
$24.96

Large
$27.04

Cauliflower
$20.80

Crustless
$11.44

Tyler’s CBR
Ranch sauce, grilled chicken, bacon, and mozzarella cheese
Personal
$13.52

Small
$22.88

Medium
$24.96

Large
$27.04

Cauliflower
$20.80

Crustless
$11.44

Cheeseburger
Ketchup and mustard drizzle base, hamburger crumbles, onion, pickles, bacon, cheddar and mozzarella cheeses
Personal
$13.52

Small
$22.88

Medium
$24.96

Large
$27.04

Cauliflower
$20.80

Crustless
$11.44

BLT
Cheddar cheese base, bacon, fresh lettuce, tomato, and a mayo drizzle
Personal
$13.52

Small
$22.88

Medium
$24.96

Large
$27.04

Cauliflower
$20.80

Crustless
$11.44

Veggie
Mushrooms, onions, green peppers, black olives, green olives, banana peppers, and tomatoes
Personal
$13.52

Small
$22.88

Medium
$24.96

Large
$27.04

Cauliflower
$20.80

Crustless
$11.44

Philly
White sauce base, seasoned philly meat, mushrooms, onion, green pepper, cheddar and mozzarella cheeses
Personal
$13.52

Small
$22.88

Medium
$24.96

Large
$27.04

Cauliflower
$20.80

Crustless
$11.44

Hawaiian
BBQ sauce, bacon, ham, pineapple, cheddar and mozzarella cheeses
Personal
$13.52

Small
$22.88

Medium
$24.96

Large
$27.04

Cauliflower
$20.80

Crustless
$11.44

Rise & Shine
Sausage gravy, scrambled eggs, italian sausage, bacon, ham, cheddar and mozzarella cheeses
Personal
$15.60

Small
$23.92

Medium
$26.00

Large
$28.08

Cauliflower
$21.84

Meat Lovers
Pepperoni, italian sausage, grilled chicken, bacon, ham, and mozzarella cheese
Personal
$15.60

Small
$23.92

Medium
$26.00

Large
$28.08

Cauliflower
$21.84

BBQ Chicken
BBQ sauce, grilled chicken, bacon, pineapple, cheddar and mozzarella cheeses, BBQ sauce drizzle
Personal
$15.60

Small
$23.92

Medium
$26.00

Large
$28.08

Cauliflower
$21.84

Super Deluxe
Pepperoni, italian sausage, bacon, ham, mushroom, onion, green pepper, black olive, banana peppers, and mozzarella cheese
Personal
$17.68

Small
$27.04

Medium
$29.12

Large
$31.02

Cauliflower
$24.96

Crustless
$15.60



BYO Pizza
Cheese included- add $1.04 per topping. Available Toppings: American Sausage, Anchovies ($4.16 on all sizes), Bacon, Chicken, Black Olives, Green Peppers, Green Olives, Hamburger, Ham, Italian Sausage, Jalapenos, Banana Peppers, Meatballs, Mushrooms, Onions, Pepperoni, Pineapple, Tomatoes

Build Your Own Pizza
Personal
$8.32

Small
$16.64

Medium
$18.72

Large
$20.80

Cauliflower
$14.56

Crustless
$6.24

Extra Cheese
Personal
$1.56

Small
$2.60

Medium
$3.12

Large
$4.16

Cauliflower
$2.08

Crustless
$1.56

Extra Veggies
per veggie - all sizes
$1.04

Extra Meats
Personal
$1.40

Small
$2.08

Medium
$2.34

Large
$2.60

Cauliflower
$1.82

Crustless
$1.04



Desserts


Chocolate Lava Cake
$5.20

Cookie Dough Bites
Deep fried cookie dough bites 10 for
$7.27

Cinna-Nom Bread
9" personal size with 1 icing
$7.23

14" family size with 2 icings
$12.43

Chocolate Pan Brownie
$7.25

Monday | Closed

Tuesday | 3 pm to 9 pm

Wednesday | 3 pm to 9 pm

Thursday | 3 pm to 9 pm

Friday | 3 pm to 10 pm

Saturday | 3 pm to 10 pm

Sunday | 3 pm to 9 pm

 

**We reserve the right to close early without notice if sales do not warrant remaining open

101 Pine St. Greenville, Ohio 45331

  • Facebook

© 2026 Teaford's Dairy Store | All Rights Reserved

bottom of page